Want AI drafts without switching email apps?
Superhuman and Shortwave are email clients. You connect Gmail or, for Superhuman, Outlook, and you work in their inbox instead of the mail app you already use. That is a good fit if you want a new inbox with built-in AI, search, and triage. It is a poor fit if you just want a draft in the thread that is already open.
paisty does not replace Mail, Outlook, Gmail in the browser, or your chat app. It is a menu-bar mark on an Apple Silicon Mac. A click reads the front window, asks the AI you already use, and puts a draft in the reply box when Accessibility is allowed. If Accessibility is off, the draft is on your clipboard, so press Cmd-V. You review it. You send it. Nothing is sent for you.
How they differ
- Where you work. Superhuman and Shortwave are the place you read and send mail. paisty leaves you in the window you already have, including Mail, a browser thread, chat, or notes.
- What it can see. Those clients work from the mailbox you connect to them. paisty does not sign into your mail. It reads the front window, and only uses other mail, chat, notes, or calendar sources if you connect them in setup and agree first.
- Which AI. paisty uses the model you point it at: a signed-in Claude, ChatGPT / Codex, or Cursor session, an API key you paste, or a local model such as Ollama or LM Studio. Bring your own AI.
- What it costs. Superhuman and Shortwave publish their own paid plans, and those numbers change, so check their sites. paisty has a free 7-day trial, one per email, then $6 a month, $60 a year, $99 lifetime, or $49 for a Founding Member lifetime key through December 31, 2026.
When to stay put
Stay in your current mail app if your rules, signatures, and accounts already work, and you mainly want help writing the next reply. Switch clients if you want a new inbox, keyboard-first triage, or an assistant that lives inside that product's mailbox.
For a closer look at menu-bar draft tools that also keep Apple Mail, see AI email reply apps for Mac, compared. For one-on-one pages, see paisty vs Superhuman and paisty vs Shortwave. For pointing paisty at a local model or your own key, see draft replies with your own AI.
Pricing · About · Support · AI email drafts · Compare apps · Your own AI · vs Superhuman · vs Shortwave · vs ChatGPT desktop · vs Raycast AI · AI in any text box · Best Mac reply tool · All answers · Privacy · Terms