paisty vs Shortwave: which job are you hiring for?

“paisty vs Shortwave” and “Shortwave alternative” sound like a head-to-head, but the products sit in different layers. Shortwave is an AI email client with its own inbox experience, available on iOS, Android, Mac, and Windows (shortwave.com, as of November 19, 2026). paisty is a menu-bar mark on an Apple Silicon Mac. A click reads the front window and drafts a reply with the AI you choose. You keep Mail, a browser thread, chat, or notes open.

If Accessibility is allowed, the draft lands in the reply box. Otherwise it sits on the clipboard, so press Cmd-V. paisty does not sign into your mail and never sends. You review and send.

Shortwave, from their public pages

paisty, in plain terms

paisty does not rebuild your mailbox. It drafts from whatever is frontmost: Apple Mail, chat, notes (Obsidian, Apple Notes, a folder), or a browser page. Bring your own AI: sign in to Claude, Codex, or Cursor; paste an API key (OpenAI, xAI Grok, Google Gemini, OpenRouter, Groq, Mistral, DeepSeek, Together, or any OpenAI-compatible URL); or run a local model such as Ollama or LM Studio. Optional voice file: ~/.config/paiste/voice.md.

After a free 7-day trial (one per email), paisty is $6/month, $60/year ($5/mo billed yearly), $99 lifetime, or $49 Founding Member lifetime through December 31, 2026. Checkout is Stripe. See pricing.

When Shortwave is the better pick

Choose Shortwave if you want a new inbox with AI filters, search, and automation, and you need the same product on phone and desktop. Cross-platform clients win when the Mac is only one of your screens. Team archive, shared discussion on threads, and built-in AI quotas are also Shortwave’s lane, not paisty’s.

When paisty is the better pick

Choose paisty if switching clients is the cost you refuse to pay. Rules, signatures, and accounts stay where they are. You only want help writing the next reply, including from chat or notes, and you want to point the draft at your own model or key. Apple Silicon Mac only.

Related reading

Also see paisty vs Superhuman, the overview of a Superhuman or Shortwave alternative that keeps your mail app, and AI email reply apps for Mac, compared.

FAQ

Start a free trial

Pricing · About · Support · AI email drafts · Compare apps · Your own AI · vs Superhuman · vs Shortwave · vs ChatGPT desktop · vs Raycast AI · AI in any text box · Best Mac reply tool · All answers · Privacy · Terms

Start a free trial