AI replies in Apple Mail: Writing Tools or paisty.
If you use Apple Mail on a Mac, you already have some AI built in. Apple's Mail guide says that with Apple Intelligence you can use Writing Tools to summarize selected text, proofread, and find the right wording and tone, and notes that Apple Intelligence is not available in all languages or regions and usage limits may apply (Apple Mail User Guide, as of November 19, 2026). paisty is a different tool for a different step: it drafts the whole reply to the thread in front of you, with the AI you choose.
Use Writing Tools when
- You already wrote the reply and want it proofread, shortened, or made friendlier.
- You want a summary of a long message you selected.
- You want something built into macOS with nothing to install, on a Mac and in a language Apple Intelligence supports.
Use paisty when
- You want the first draft written for you, from the thread already open.
- You want to pick the model: Claude, Codex, Cursor, an API key such as OpenAI or Gemini, or a local model such as Ollama or LM Studio.
- You also reply outside Mail. The same click works in Outlook, Gmail in a browser, Slack, and other windows.
- You want your own tone file at ~/.config/paiste/voice.md used on every draft.
They work together
Nothing stops you using both. Click the paisty mark to get a draft in the Mail reply box, then select it and use Writing Tools to adjust the tone. paisty never presses Return, so the message waits for you.
How it works in Mail
- Open the message in the app you already use.
- Click the paisty mark in the menu bar.
- Read the draft in the reply box (or press Cmd-V if Accessibility is off). Edit anything that is off, or redo it from the menu.
- Send it yourself. paisty never presses Return.
With Accessibility allowed once, the draft goes straight into the Mail reply box. Without it, the draft is on your clipboard. paisty does not sign into your iCloud, Gmail, or Exchange account. It reads the message on screen when you click.
Price
Writing Tools comes with Apple Intelligence on supported Macs. paisty is a separate app: Free 7-day trial, one per email. Then $6/month, $60/year, $99 lifetime, or $49 for a Founding Member lifetime key through December 31, 2026. Checkout is Stripe. Details: pricing. Your AI provider bills separately if it charges. paisty runs on Apple Silicon Macs.
More on mail apps: Gmail, Outlook, and Mail on a Mac.
FAQ
- Does Apple Mail have AI replies built in? Apple's Mail guide describes Apple Intelligence Writing Tools for summarizing, proofreading, and rewording, with language, region, and usage limits. Check Apple's guide for what your Mac supports.
- How is paisty different from Writing Tools? paisty drafts the whole reply from the open thread with the model you choose. Writing Tools mainly rewrites, proofreads, and summarizes text.
- Does paisty work inside Apple Mail? Yes. Open the message, click the paisty mark, and with Accessibility allowed the draft lands in the reply box.
- Does paisty need my iCloud or email password? No. It reads the message on screen and never signs into your mail.
Related
- AI email replies in Outlook for Mac: Copilot or paisty
- AI replies to Gmail on a Mac: Gemini Help me write or paisty
- Use ChatGPT or Claude for email replies without copy and paste
- All answers
Pricing · About · Support · AI email drafts · Compare apps · Your own AI · vs Superhuman · vs Shortwave · vs ChatGPT desktop · vs Raycast AI · AI in any text box · Best Mac reply tool · All answers · Privacy · Terms